Resumen de For and against: Leos Carax

Jonathan Romney, Robert Koehler

• While still in his 20s he shot to arthouse fame-and gave the world Juliette Binoche-before blowing it all on the big-budget flop Les Amants du Pont-Neuf. Now past 50, he's back after a long, long absence with a film that divided the critics at Cannes, Holy Motors. But should we still care? Two S & S contributors thrash it out.