Shifting Conceptions of Sexual Discrimination at the Court of Justice: from P v S to Grant v SWT

• Autores: Mark Bell
• Localización: European Law Journal, ISSN-e 1468-0386, Vol. 5, Nº. 1, 1999, págs. 63-81
• Idioma: inglés
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Dialnet Métricas: 4 Citas
• Resumen

  • Decisions of the Court of Justice have challenged traditional notions of sexual discrimination. In P v S and Cornwall County Council, the Court held that discrimination against transsexuals was contrary to the 1976 Equal Treatment Directive. However, in Grant v South‐West Trains, the Court rejected arguments that Article 119 on equal pay prohibited discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. This article contrasts the two decisions, and in particular focuses on the inconsistencies in the Court’s definition of what constitutes sexual discrimination. The article further considers the underlying factors which may have influenced the Court’s judgment, including the moral dimension and the political context of the two decisions. Finally, there is a discussion of the merits of equality litigation strategies, in particular at the Court of Justice.