Resumen de Evaluation of three "Brettanomyces" qPCR commercial kits: results from an interlaboratory study
Cédric Longin, Frédérique Julliat, Virginie Serpaggi, Julie Maupeu, Geoffrey Bourbon, Sandrine Rousseaux, Michèle Guilloux-Benatier, Hervé Alexandre
"Brettanomyces bruxellensis" is well adapted to high ethanol concentrations and low pH which allows it to develop in difficult environments, such as wine. B. bruxellensis is mainly found in red wine and is regarded as a spoilage yeast due to its production of ethylphenols and other compounds responsible for organoleptic defects. The detection and quantification of this yeast is essential to preventing wine spoilage. Several specific detection and quantification kits based on real time quantitative PCR are commercially available. Although these kits are frequently used by private enological and research laboratories, no scientific report on the reliability and performance of these kits, including inter-laboratory and inter-assay comparisons have been published. The aim of this work was to compare available kits to quantify B. bruxellensis in red wine to classical method (plate counting on selective medium) in an interlaboratory study. Three different commercial kits were tested on three different wines from Bordeaux, Côtes du Rhône, and Burgundy inoculated with B. bruxellensis at four different concentrations. Five naturally contaminated wines from different French wine regions were also tested. Our results suggest that all the kits tested probably over or underestimate the quantity of B. bruxellensis in red wine and, under specific conditions, give false positives. Quantification may be very heterogeneous depending on the wine, laboratory, or population level. Underestimations or false negative results may have serious consequences for winemakers. Overestimation may be partly due to the quantification of dead cells qPCR.
This study highlights that quantification of B. bruxellensis in red wine using commercial kits requires a high level of expertise in molecular biology. We recommend that all users use a microbiological internal control to validate DNA extraction yield.
